1975 – Bethany Assembly of God

1976 – Bethany Assembly of God

1977 – First Central Baptist

1978 – Union

1979 – Church in the Acres Baptist

1980 – First Pentecostal

1981 – Blessed Hope Advent Christian

1982 – Bethany Assembly of God

1983 – Bethlehem Baptist

1984 – Trinity United Methodist

1985 – Christian Life Center

1986 – Foster Memorial

1987 – Evangelical Covenant

1988 – Bethany Assembly of God

1989 – Foster Memorial

1990 – Bethany Assembly of God #1

1991 – Bethany Assembly of God #1

1992 – Bethany Assembly of God #1

1993 – First Central Baptist

1994 – Faith Bible

1995 – Bethlehem Baptist

1996 – Union

1997 – Evangel Assembly of God

1998 – Church of Redemption

1999 – Tabernacle Baptist

2000

National – Bethany Assembly of God #2

American – Heritage Baptist

2001

National – Bethany Assembly of God #2

American – Church of Christ

2002

National – Koinonia

American – Church of Redemption

2003

National – Koinonia

American – Union

2004

“A” Division – Bethany Assembly of God #1

“B” Division – Enfield Community

“C” Division – Westfield Evangelical Free

2005

“A” Division – Koinonia

“B” Division – Heritage Baptist

“C” Division – Trinity United Methodist

2006

“A” Division – Bethany Assembly of God #1

“B” Division – Foster Memorial

“C” Division – Bethany Assembly of God #3

2007

“A” Division – Bethany Assembly of God #1

“B” Division – First Baptist

“C” Division – First Central Baptist

2008

“A” Division – Bethany Assembly of God #1

“B” Division – Heritage Baptist

“C” Division – Trinity United Methodist

Co-Ed Division – Bethany Assembly of God #2

2009

“A” Division – Well Spring

“B” Division – Trinity #1

“C” Division – none

Co-Ed Division – Christ Presbyterian

2010

“A” Division – Pioneer Valley Assembly of God

“B” Division – Word of Grace

“C” Division – Foster Memorial

Co-Ed Division – Bethany Assembly of God #1

2011

“A” Division – New Life Christian & Bethany

Assembly of God #1

“B” Division – Trinity #1

“C” Division – Christ Life Fellowship

Co-Ed Division – Bethany Assembly of God #1

2012

“A” Division – Bethany Assembly of God #1

“B” Division – Christ Life Fellowship

“C” Division – LifePoint

Co-Ed Division – Bethany Assembly of God #1

2013

“A” Division – City Church

“B” Division – Trinity

“C” Division – Hope Community

Co-Ed Division – Christ Community

2014

“A” Division – Trinity

“B” Division – Christ Presbyterian

“C” Division – Evangel

Co-Ed Division – Christ Community

2015

“A” Division – United Bible

“B” Division – Harvest Bible

“C” Division – Mt View Baptist

Co-Ed Division – Christ Community

2016

“A” Division – Bethany Assembly of God #1

“B” Division – Evangel

“C” Division – Church of Redemption

Co-Ed Division – Christ Community

2017

“A” Division – Bethany Assembly of God #1

“B” Division – Christ Community

“C” Division – Church of Redemption

Co-Ed Division – Christ Community